[scheduler] fix scheduling behavior of batch job allocs

Allocations of batch jobs have a few defined behaviors documented
which do not work as expected:

First, on node drain, the allocation is allowed to complete unless
the deadline is reached at which point the allocation is killed. The
allocation is note replaced.

Second, when using the `alloc stop` command, the allocation is
stopped and then rescheduled according to its reschedule policy.

Third, on job restart if the `-reschedule` flag is used the
allocation will be migrated and its reschedule policy will be
ignored.

This update removes the change introduced in dfa07e1 (#26025)
that forced batch job allocations into a failed state when
migrating. The reported issue it was attempting to resolve was
itself incorrect behavior. The reconciler has been adjusted
to properly handle batch job allocations as documented.

Author: chrisroberts

.changelog/26961.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+```release-note:bug
+scheduler: Fixed scheduling behavior of batch job allocations
+```

api/allocations.go

@@ -185,24 +185,10 @@ func (a *Allocations) RestartAllTasks(alloc *Allocation, q *QueryOptions) error
 // Note: for cluster topologies where API consumers don't have network access to
 // Nomad clients, set api.ClientConnTimeout to a small value (ex 1ms) to avoid
 // long pauses on this API call.
-//
-// BREAKING: This method will have the following signature in 1.6.0
-// func (a *Allocations) Stop(allocID string, w *WriteOptions) (*AllocStopResponse, error) {
 func (a *Allocations) Stop(alloc *Allocation, q *QueryOptions) (*AllocStopResponse, error) {
-	// COMPAT: Remove in 1.6.0
-	var w *WriteOptions
-	if q != nil {
-		w = &WriteOptions{
-			Region:    q.Region,
-			Namespace: q.Namespace,
-			AuthToken: q.AuthToken,
-			Headers:   q.Headers,
-			ctx:       q.ctx,
-		}
-	}
-
 	var resp AllocStopResponse
-	wm, err := a.client.put("/v1/allocation/"+alloc.ID+"/stop", nil, &resp, w)
+
+	wm, err := a.client.putQuery("/v1/allocation/"+alloc.ID+"/stop", nil, &resp, q)
 	if wm != nil {
 		resp.LastIndex = wm.LastIndex
 		resp.RequestTime = wm.RequestTime
@@ -590,13 +576,46 @@ type DesiredTransition struct {
 	// Reschedule is used to indicate that this allocation is eligible to be
 	// rescheduled.
 	Reschedule *bool
+
+	// ForceReschedule is used to indicate that this allocation must be
+	// rescheduled.
+	ForceReschedule *bool
+
+	// NoShutdownDelay is used to indicate any configured shutdown delay
+	// should be ignored.
+	NoShutdownDelay *bool
+
+	// MigrateDisablePlacement is used to indicate that this allocation
+	// should not be placed during migration.
+	MigrateDisablePlacement *bool
 }
 
 // ShouldMigrate returns whether the transition object dictates a migration.
 func (d DesiredTransition) ShouldMigrate() bool {
 	return d.Migrate != nil && *d.Migrate
 }
 
+// ShouldReschedule returns whether the transition object dictates a reschedule.
+func (d DesiredTransition) ShouldReschedule() bool {
+	return d.Reschedule != nil && *d.Reschedule
+}
+
+// ShouldIgnoreShutdownDelay returns whether the transition object dictates
+// ignoring the configured shutdown delay.
+func (d DesiredTransition) ShouldIgnoreShutdownDelay() bool {
+	return d.NoShutdownDelay != nil && *d.NoShutdownDelay
+}
+
+// ShouldForceReschedule returns whether the transition object dictates a forced reschedule.
+func (d DesiredTransition) ShouldForceReschedule() bool {
+	return d.ForceReschedule != nil && *d.ForceReschedule
+}
+
+// ShouldDisableMigrationPlacement returns whether the transition object dictates placement during migration
+func (d DesiredTransition) ShouldDisableMigrationPlacement() bool {
+	return d.MigrateDisablePlacement != nil && *d.MigrateDisablePlacement
+}
+
 // ExecStreamingIOOperation represents a stream write operation: either appending data or close (exclusively)
 type ExecStreamingIOOperation struct {
 	Data  []byte `json:"data,omitempty"`

api/allocations_test.go

@@ -319,34 +319,100 @@ func TestAllocations_Stop(t *testing.T) {
 	testutil.RequireRoot(t)
 	testutil.Parallel(t)
 
-	c, s := makeClient(t, nil, func(c *testutil.TestServerConfig) {
-		c.DevMode = true
+	t.Run("default", func(t *testing.T) {
+		c, s := makeClient(t, nil, func(c *testutil.TestServerConfig) {
+			c.DevMode = true
+		})
+		defer s.Stop()
+		a := c.Allocations()
+
+		// wait for node
+		_ = oneNodeFromNodeList(t, c.Nodes())
+
+		// Create a job and register it
+		job := testJob()
+		_, wm, err := c.Jobs().Register(job, nil)
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+
+		// List allocations.
+		stubs, qm, err := a.List(&QueryOptions{WaitIndex: wm.LastIndex})
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+		must.SliceLen(t, 1, stubs)
+
+		// Stop the first allocation.
+		resp, err := a.Stop(&Allocation{ID: stubs[0].ID}, &QueryOptions{WaitIndex: qm.LastIndex})
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+		test.UUIDv4(t, resp.EvalID)
+		test.NonZero(t, resp.LastIndex)
+
+		// Stop allocation that doesn't exist.
+		resp, err = a.Stop(&Allocation{ID: "invalid"}, &QueryOptions{WaitIndex: qm.LastIndex})
+		must.Error(t, err)
 	})
-	defer s.Stop()
-	a := c.Allocations()
 
-	// wait for node
-	_ = oneNodeFromNodeList(t, c.Nodes())
-
-	// Create a job and register it
-	job := testJob()
-	_, wm, err := c.Jobs().Register(job, nil)
-	must.NoError(t, err)
+	t.Run("rescheduled", func(t *testing.T) {
+		c, s := makeClient(t, nil, func(c *testutil.TestServerConfig) {
+			c.DevMode = true
+		})
+		defer s.Stop()
+		a := c.Allocations()
+
+		// wait for node
+		_ = oneNodeFromNodeList(t, c.Nodes())
+
+		// Create a job and register it
+		job := testJob()
+		_, wm, err := c.Jobs().Register(job, nil)
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+
+		// List allocations.
+		stubs, qm, err := a.List(&QueryOptions{WaitIndex: wm.LastIndex})
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+		must.SliceLen(t, 1, stubs)
+
+		// Stop the first allocation.
+		resp, err := a.Stop(&Allocation{ID: stubs[0].ID}, &QueryOptions{
+			Params:    map[string]string{"reschedule": "true"},
+			WaitIndex: qm.LastIndex,
+		})
+		must.NoError(t, err)
 
-	// List allocations.
-	stubs, qm, err := a.List(&QueryOptions{WaitIndex: wm.LastIndex})
-	must.NoError(t, err)
-	must.SliceLen(t, 1, stubs)
+		alloc, _, err := a.Info(stubs[0].ID, &QueryOptions{WaitIndex: resp.LastIndex})
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+		must.True(t, alloc.DesiredTransition.ShouldReschedule(), must.Sprint("allocation should be marked for rescheduling"))
+	})
 
-	// Stop the first allocation.
-	resp, err := a.Stop(&Allocation{ID: stubs[0].ID}, &QueryOptions{WaitIndex: qm.LastIndex})
-	must.NoError(t, err)
-	test.UUIDv4(t, resp.EvalID)
-	test.NonZero(t, resp.LastIndex)
+	t.Run("no shutdown delay", func(t *testing.T) {
+		c, s := makeClient(t, nil, func(c *testutil.TestServerConfig) {
+			c.DevMode = true
+		})
+		defer s.Stop()
+		a := c.Allocations()
+
+		// wait for node
+		_ = oneNodeFromNodeList(t, c.Nodes())
+
+		// Create a job and register it
+		job := testJob()
+		_, wm, err := c.Jobs().Register(job, nil)
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+
+		// List allocations.
+		stubs, qm, err := a.List(&QueryOptions{WaitIndex: wm.LastIndex})
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+		must.SliceLen(t, 1, stubs)
+
+		// Stop the first allocation.
+		resp, err := a.Stop(&Allocation{ID: stubs[0].ID}, &QueryOptions{
+			Params:    map[string]string{"no_shutdown_delay": "true"},
+			WaitIndex: qm.LastIndex,
+		})
+		must.NoError(t, err)
 
-	// Stop allocation that doesn't exist.
-	resp, err = a.Stop(&Allocation{ID: "invalid"}, &QueryOptions{WaitIndex: qm.LastIndex})
-	must.Error(t, err)
+		alloc, _, err := a.Info(stubs[0].ID, &QueryOptions{WaitIndex: resp.LastIndex})
+		must.NoError(t, err)
+		must.True(t, alloc.DesiredTransition.ShouldIgnoreShutdownDelay(), must.Sprint("allocation should be marked for no shutdown delay"))
+	})
 }
 
 // TestAllocations_ExecErrors ensures errors are properly formatted
@@ -480,6 +546,38 @@ func TestAllocations_ShouldMigrate(t *testing.T) {
 	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{Migrate: pointerOf(false)}.ShouldMigrate())
 }
 
+func TestAllocations_ShouldReschedule(t *testing.T) {
+	testutil.Parallel(t)
+
+	must.True(t, DesiredTransition{Reschedule: pointerOf(true)}.ShouldReschedule())
+	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{}.ShouldReschedule())
+	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{Reschedule: pointerOf(false)}.ShouldReschedule())
+}
+
+func TestAllocations_ShouldForceReschedule(t *testing.T) {
+	testutil.Parallel(t)
+
+	must.True(t, DesiredTransition{ForceReschedule: pointerOf(true)}.ShouldForceReschedule())
+	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{}.ShouldForceReschedule())
+	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{ForceReschedule: pointerOf(false)}.ShouldForceReschedule())
+}
+
+func TestAllocations_ShouldIgnoreShutdownDelay(t *testing.T) {
+	testutil.Parallel(t)
+
+	must.True(t, DesiredTransition{NoShutdownDelay: pointerOf(true)}.ShouldIgnoreShutdownDelay())
+	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{}.ShouldIgnoreShutdownDelay())
+	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{NoShutdownDelay: pointerOf(false)}.ShouldIgnoreShutdownDelay())
+}
+
+func TestAllocations_ShouldDisableMigrationPlacement(t *testing.T) {
+	testutil.Parallel(t)
+
+	must.True(t, DesiredTransition{MigrateDisablePlacement: pointerOf(true)}.ShouldDisableMigrationPlacement())
+	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{}.ShouldDisableMigrationPlacement())
+	must.False(t, DesiredTransition{MigrateDisablePlacement: pointerOf(false)}.ShouldDisableMigrationPlacement())
+}
+
 func TestAllocations_Services(t *testing.T) {
 	t.Skip("needs to be implemented")
 	// TODO(jrasell) add tests once registration process is in place.

client/allocrunner/alloc_runner.go

@@ -737,23 +737,8 @@ func (ar *allocRunner) killTasks() map[string]*structs.TaskState {
 			return nil
 		}
 
-		te := structs.NewTaskEvent(structs.TaskKilling).
+		return structs.NewTaskEvent(structs.TaskKilling).
 			SetKillTimeout(tr.Task().KillTimeout, ar.clientConfig.MaxKillTimeout)
-
-		// if the task is not set failed, the job type is batch, and the
-		// allocation is being migrated then mark the task as failed. this
-		// ensures the task is recreated if no eligible nodes are immediately
-		// available.
-		if !tr.TaskState().Failed &&
-			ar.alloc.Job.Type == structs.JobTypeBatch &&
-			ar.alloc.DesiredTransition.Migrate != nil &&
-			*ar.alloc.DesiredTransition.Migrate {
-
-			ar.logger.Trace("marking migrating batch job task failed on kill", "task_name", tr.Task().Name)
-			te.SetFailsTask()
-		}
-
-		return te
 	}
 
 	// Kill leader first, synchronously