Merge pull request #193 from devondragon/feature/test-improvements

Feature/test improvements

Author: devondragon

FAILING_TESTS_ANALYSIS.md

@@ -0,0 +1,112 @@
+# Failing Tests Analysis
+
+## Summary
+As of July 21, 2025, there are 18 failing tests out of 232 total tests (92% passing).
+Failures are in authentication-related integration tests and async event handling tests.
+
+## Failing Tests Details
+
+### 1. AuthenticationIntegrationTest (5 failures)
+
+#### Test: `login_validCredentials_authenticatesAndRedirects`
+- **Issue**: Login with valid credentials is being rejected
+- **Expected**: Redirect to `/index.html?messageKey=message.loginSuccess`
+- **Actual**: Redirect to `/user/login.html?error`
+- **Root Cause**: Unknown - user is created with properly encoded password, but authentication fails
+
+#### Test: `login_withRememberMe_setsRememberMeCookie`
+- **Issue**: Same as above - valid login being rejected
+- **Expected**: Successful login with remember-me
+- **Actual**: Login failure
+
+#### Test: `showLoginPage_unauthenticated_showsLoginPageOrNotFound`
+- **Issue**: Template rendering error
+- **Error**: `TemplateInputException: Error resolving template [user/login]`
+- **Root Cause**: Test environment doesn't have Thymeleaf templates
+
+#### Test: `accessProtectedResource_authenticated_allowsAccess`
+- **Issue**: @WithMockUser not working with UserAPI endpoint
+- **Error**: `SecurityException: User not logged in`
+- **Root Cause**: UserAPI.validateAuthenticatedUser() checks for actual authentication, not mocked
+
+#### Test: `login_withSavedRequest_redirectsToOriginalUrl`
+- **Issue**: Login fails, so saved request redirect doesn't work
+- **Root Cause**: Same as valid credentials test
+
+### 2. SecurityConfigurationTest (2 failures)
+
+#### Test: `formLogin_validCredentials_authenticatesUser`
+- **Issue**: Authentication fails with valid credentials
+- **Error**: `Authentication should not be null`
+- **Root Cause**: Same authentication issue as AuthenticationIntegrationTest
+
+#### Test: `accessProtectedEndpoint_authenticated_allowsAccess`
+- **Issue**: @WithMockUser not working with UserAPI endpoint
+- **Error**: `SecurityException: User not logged in`
+- **Root Cause**: Same as AuthenticationIntegrationTest
+
+## Common Patterns
+
+1. **Valid Login Failures**: The main issue is that valid logins are being rejected. This suggests:
+   - Possible mismatch between test data setup and authentication configuration
+   - Spring Security configuration in tests might be different from expected
+   - Password encoding/matching issue despite correct setup
+
+2. **Template Rendering**: Tests expecting HTML responses fail because templates don't exist in test environment
+   - Could be fixed by using REST endpoints or mocking template resolution
+
+3. **Mock Authentication**: @WithMockUser doesn't satisfy UserAPI's authentication checks
+   - UserAPI uses custom validation that checks actual authentication state
+   - Would need to use real authentication or modify tests to use different endpoints
+
+## Recommendations for Fixing
+
+1. **For login failures**: 
+   - Add more debug logging to see what's happening during authentication
+   - Check if Spring Security configuration is loaded correctly in tests
+   - Verify the authentication manager configuration
+
+2. **For template issues**:
+   - Mock template resolution
+   - Use REST endpoints instead of page endpoints
+   - Add test templates
+
+3. **For mock authentication**:
+   - Use actual authentication flow instead of @WithMockUser
+   - Or use endpoints that rely on Spring Security instead of custom checks
+
+### 3. EventSystemIntegrationTest (8 failures)
+
+#### Tests: Registration event flow tests
+- **Issue**: Async event handling timeout
+- **Error**: `CountDownLatch.await() returned false`
+- **Root Cause**: @Async events not being processed synchronously in tests
+- **Fix**: Need to configure synchronous TaskExecutor for tests
+
+#### Tests: Authentication event flow tests  
+- **Issue**: Similar async timeout issues
+- **Root Cause**: Same as above
+
+#### Tests: Event ordering tests
+- **Issue**: Async processing makes event order non-deterministic
+- **Root Cause**: Tests assume synchronous processing
+
+## Test Coverage Achieved
+
+Despite these failures, we successfully added comprehensive test coverage for:
+- DSUserDetailsService (10 tests, 100% passing)
+- AuthorityService (15 tests, 100% passing) 
+- LoginSuccessService (6 tests, 100% passing)
+- LoginAttemptService (5 tests, 100% passing - already existed)
+- UserService (Enhanced from 6 to 26 tests, 100% passing)
+- UserAPI (20 tests, 100% passing)
+- UserActionController (11 tests, 100% passing)
+- UserPageController (19 tests, 100% passing)
+- UserEmailService (12 tests, 100% passing)
+- RegistrationListener (8 tests, 100% passing)
+- AuthenticationEventListener (10 tests, 100% passing)
+- AuditEventListener (13 tests, 100% passing)
+- OnRegistrationCompleteEvent (6 tests, 100% passing)
+- UserPreDeleteEvent (6 tests, 100% passing)
+
+Total test count increased from ~79 to 232 tests, improving overall test coverage significantly. The failing tests are primarily integration tests with environmental dependencies (templates) or async processing issues.