Skip to content

Use context to prioritize or only show case and default in a switch statement #52234

@DanielRosenwasser

Description

@DanielRosenwasser

While playing around with switch/case snippets, I ran into the following:

switch (someValue) {
    /**/
}

Request completions at /**/

The only completions that should be offered here are case and default (along with corresponding snippet completions). It's bad that we don't do that because these keywords are always sorted to come after any other invalid completions.

Fixing just this is one small case. If we wanted to go deeper, I would propose that we use the line and column of the current case or default clause to inform what completions we offer.

Some test cases I would want to remain the same or change:

// same - show all completions
switch (thing) {
  case 42:
  /*$*/
}
// same - show all completions
switch (thing) {
  case 42:
  break;
  /*$*/
}
// same - show all completions
switch (thing) {
  case 42:
  if (Math.random()) {
  }
  else {
  }
  /*$*/
}
// NEW - prioritize `case`/`default`
switch (thing) {
  case 42:
    break;
  /*$*/
}
// NEW - prioritize `case`/`default`
switch (thing) {
  case 42: break;
  /*$*/
}
// NEW - prioritize `case`/`default`
switch (thing) {
  case 42: {
  }
  break;
  /*$*/
}

The current closest approximation I can think of is:

  • the cursor is at the same column as the containing clause's case/default keyword, but on a different line, and
  • there is at least one statement in the clause, and any of the following are true:
    • the last statement is one that would jump out of the current control flow (e.g. break/return/throw/continue)
    • the start of the last statement's token is on a different line and column as the containing clause's case/default keyword

then we should actually ensure case and default appear at the top.

This case:

// NEW - prioritize `case`/`default`/`break`
switch (thing) {
  case 42: {
    // ...
  }
  /*$*/
}

is one that might get another special-case where we'd possibly want to provide break if we don't see it as the last statement of the block. But I'm curious to hear others' thoughts.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Domain: Completion ListsThe issue relates to showing completion lists in an editorIn DiscussionNot yet reached consensusSuggestionAn idea for TypeScript

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions