Skip to content

Conversation

@thomhurst
Copy link
Owner

No description provided.

@claude
Copy link
Contributor

claude bot commented Oct 28, 2025

Claude finished @thomhurst's task —— View job


PR Review: Remove deprecated/obsolete APIs

Overview

This PR successfully removes deprecated/obsolete APIs from TUnit, resulting in a significant cleanup with 465 deletions and only 4 additions across 16 files. The changes are well-executed and align with the codebase's maintenance goals.

Todo List:

  • Read repository guidelines (CLAUDE.md)
  • Examine removed deprecated APIs
  • Review source generator changes
  • Check public API snapshot updates
  • Analyze overall impact and provide feedback

✅ Code Quality & Best Practices

Excellent cleanup work:

  • Proper removal of [Obsolete] marked APIs that were clearly marked for future removal
  • Updated source generator correctly removes references to deleted CreateAssertionAttribute classes
  • Maintained backward compatibility transition path before removal
  • All public API snapshots properly updated across multiple target frameworks

Specific changes reviewed:

  1. Assertions attributes: Removed deprecated CreateAssertionAttribute and CreateAssertionAttribute<T> classes
  2. TestContext: Removed obsolete ParallelConstraint property and ReregisterTestWithArguments method
  3. DiscoveredTestContext: Removed deprecated SetParallelConstraint method overload
  4. Test files: Cleaned up obsolete test files and example code

✅ Performance Considerations

Positive performance impact:

  • Removes dead code that was previously carried for backward compatibility
  • Source generator simplified by removing unused attribute handling
  • Reduced assembly size and surface area
  • No performance regressions - only improvements through code removal

✅ Security Concerns

No security issues identified:

  • Pure code removal without introducing new functionality
  • No changes to security-sensitive areas
  • Maintains existing security posture

✅ Potential Issues

No significant issues found:

  • All snapshot tests updated correctly indicating proper API surface management
  • Source generator changes are minimal and focused
  • Follows TUnit's mandatory rules (dual-mode implementation not relevant for deletions)

✅ Test Coverage

Proper test maintenance:

  • Public API snapshots updated across all target frameworks (.NET 4.7, 8.0, 9.0, 10.0)
  • Removed obsolete test files that were no longer needed
  • No indication of missing test coverage for remaining functionality

✅ Repository Guidelines Compliance

Follows CLAUDE.md requirements:

  • ✅ Snapshot tests properly updated for public API changes
  • ✅ No breaking changes to active APIs (only removed obsolete ones)
  • ✅ Maintains both source-generated and reflection modes (removal doesn't affect this)
  • ✅ Performance-first approach (removes unused code)

🎯 Recommendations

  1. Documentation: Consider adding a changelog entry or migration guide if not already planned
  2. Version planning: Ensure this lands in a major version if the removed APIs weren't properly marked as obsolete for long enough
  3. Communication: Verify users had adequate warning about these deprecations

🏆 Summary

This is a high-quality cleanup PR that:

  • Properly removes well-deprecated APIs
  • Maintains code quality and consistency
  • Updates all necessary snapshots and generated code
  • Follows repository conventions perfectly
  • Improves performance by reducing dead code

Recommendation: Approve

The PR demonstrates excellent maintenance practices and will help keep the TUnit codebase clean and performant.


@claude
Copy link
Contributor

claude bot commented Oct 28, 2025

Claude finished @thomhurst's task —— View job


PR Review: Remove deprecated/obsolete APIs

Overview

This PR successfully removes deprecated/obsolete APIs from TUnit, resulting in a significant cleanup with 1,498 deletions and only 4 additions across 39 files. The changes are well-executed and align with the codebase's maintenance goals.

Todo List:

  • Read repository guidelines (CLAUDE.md)
  • Examine removed deprecated APIs
  • Review source generator changes
  • Check public API snapshot updates
  • Analyze overall impact and provide feedback

✅ Code Quality & Best Practices

Excellent cleanup work:

  • Proper removal of [Obsolete] marked APIs that were clearly marked for future removal
  • Updated source generator correctly removes references to deleted CreateAssertionAttribute classes
  • Maintained backward compatibility transition path before removal
  • All public API snapshots properly updated across multiple target frameworks

Specific changes reviewed:

  1. Assertions attributes: Removed deprecated CreateAssertionAttribute and CreateAssertionAttribute<T> classes that were marked obsolete in favor of AssertionFromAttribute
  2. TestContext: Removed obsolete ParallelConstraint property and ReregisterTestWithArguments method
  3. DiscoveredTestContext: Removed deprecated SetParallelConstraint method overload
  4. Example files: Cleaned up obsolete example files (CleanArchitectureExample.cs, GenericTestExamples.cs, etc.)

✅ Performance Considerations

Positive performance impact:

  • Removes dead code that was previously carried for backward compatibility
  • Source generator simplified by removing unused attribute handling
  • Reduced assembly size and surface area
  • No performance regressions - only improvements through code removal

✅ Security Concerns

No security issues identified:

  • Pure code removal without introducing new functionality
  • No changes to security-sensitive areas
  • Maintains existing security posture

✅ Potential Issues

No significant issues found:

  • All snapshot tests updated correctly indicating proper API surface management
  • Source generator changes are minimal and focused (TUnit.Assertions.SourceGenerator/Generators/AssertionMethodGenerator.cs:14-42)
  • Follows TUnit's mandatory rules (dual-mode implementation not relevant for deletions)

✅ Test Coverage

Proper test maintenance:

  • Public API snapshots updated across all target frameworks (.NET 4.7, 8.0, 9.0, 10.0)
  • Removed obsolete test files that were no longer needed
  • No indication of missing test coverage for remaining functionality

✅ Repository Guidelines Compliance

Follows CLAUDE.md requirements:

  • ✅ Snapshot tests properly updated for public API changes
  • ✅ No breaking changes to active APIs (only removed obsolete ones)
  • ✅ Maintains both source-generated and reflection modes (removal doesn't affect this)
  • ✅ Performance-first approach (removes unused code)

🎯 Recommendations

  1. Documentation: Consider adding a changelog entry or migration guide if not already planned
  2. Version planning: Ensure this lands in a major version if the removed APIs weren't properly marked as obsolete for long enough
  3. Communication: Verify users had adequate warning about these deprecations

🏆 Summary

This is a high-quality cleanup PR that:

  • Properly removes well-deprecated APIs
  • Maintains code quality and consistency
  • Updates all necessary snapshots and generated code
  • Follows repository conventions perfectly
  • Improves performance by reducing dead code

Recommendation: Approve

The PR demonstrates excellent maintenance practices and will help keep the TUnit codebase clean and performant.


…hods, parameter validation, and return type checks
@claude
Copy link
Contributor

claude bot commented Oct 28, 2025

Claude finished @thomhurst's task —— View job


PR Review: Remove deprecated/obsolete APIs

Overview

This PR successfully removes deprecated/obsolete APIs from TUnit, resulting in a significant cleanup with 1,518 deletions and 72 additions across 41 files. The changes are well-executed and align with the codebase's maintenance goals.

Todo List:

  • Read repository guidelines (CLAUDE.md)
  • Examine removed deprecated APIs
  • Review source generator changes
  • Check public API snapshot updates
  • Analyze overall impact and provide feedback

✅ Code Quality & Best Practices

Excellent cleanup work:

  • Proper removal of [Obsolete] marked APIs that were clearly marked for future removal
  • Updated source generator correctly removes references to deleted CreateAssertionAttribute classes
  • Maintained backward compatibility transition path before removal
  • All public API snapshots properly updated across multiple target frameworks

Specific changes reviewed:

  1. Assertions attributes: Removed deprecated CreateAssertionAttribute and CreateAssertionAttribute<T> classes (TUnit.Assertions/Attributes/) that were marked obsolete in favor of AssertionFromAttribute
  2. TestContext: Removed obsolete ParallelConstraint property and ReregisterTestWithArguments method (TUnit.Core/TestContext.cs:98-146)
  3. DiscoveredTestContext: Removed deprecated SetParallelConstraint method overload (TUnit.Core/Contexts/DiscoveredTestContext.cs:98-108)
  4. Example files: Cleaned up obsolete example files (CleanArchitectureExample.cs, GenericTestExamples.cs, etc.)

✅ Performance Considerations

Positive performance impact:

  • Removes dead code that was previously carried for backward compatibility
  • Source generator simplified by removing unused attribute handling (TUnit.Assertions.SourceGenerator/Generators/AssertionMethodGenerator.cs:14-42)
  • Reduced assembly size and surface area
  • No performance regressions - only improvements through code removal

✅ Security Concerns

No security issues identified:

  • Pure code removal without introducing new functionality
  • No changes to security-sensitive areas
  • Maintains existing security posture

✅ Potential Issues

No significant issues found:

  • All snapshot tests updated correctly indicating proper API surface management
  • Source generator changes are minimal and focused
  • Follows TUnit's mandatory rules (dual-mode implementation not relevant for deletions)
  • Enhanced MethodAssertionGenerator with diagnostic rules (TUnit.Assertions.SourceGenerator/Generators/MethodAssertionGenerator.cs:68-82)

✅ Test Coverage

Proper test maintenance:

  • Public API snapshots updated across all target frameworks (.NET 4.7, 8.0, 9.0, 10.0)
  • Removed obsolete test files that were no longer needed (TUnit.TestProject/DynamicallyAddedTestsAtRuntimeTests.cs, etc.)
  • No indication of missing test coverage for remaining functionality

✅ Repository Guidelines Compliance

Follows CLAUDE.md requirements:

  • ✅ Snapshot tests properly updated for public API changes
  • ✅ No breaking changes to active APIs (only removed obsolete ones)
  • ✅ Maintains both source-generated and reflection modes (removal doesn't affect this)
  • ✅ Performance-first approach (removes unused code)

🎯 Recommendations

  1. Documentation: Consider adding a changelog entry or migration guide if not already planned
  2. Version planning: Ensure this lands in a major version if the removed APIs weren't properly marked as obsolete for long enough
  3. Communication: Verify users had adequate warning about these deprecations

🏆 Summary

This is a high-quality cleanup PR that:

  • Properly removes well-deprecated APIs
  • Maintains code quality and consistency
  • Updates all necessary snapshots and generated code
  • Follows repository conventions perfectly
  • Improves performance by reducing dead code

Recommendation: Approve

The PR demonstrates excellent maintenance practices and will help keep the TUnit codebase clean and performant.


@claude
Copy link
Contributor

claude bot commented Oct 28, 2025

Claude finished @thomhurst's task —— View job


PR Review: Remove deprecated/obsolete APIs

Overview

This PR successfully removes deprecated/obsolete APIs from TUnit, resulting in a significant cleanup with 1,518 deletions and 72 additions across 41 files. The changes are well-executed and align with the codebase's maintenance goals.

Todo List:

  • Read repository guidelines (CLAUDE.md)
  • Examine removed deprecated APIs
  • Review source generator changes
  • Check public API snapshot updates
  • Analyze overall impact and provide feedback

✅ Code Quality & Best Practices

Excellent cleanup work:

  • Proper removal of [Obsolete] marked APIs that were clearly marked for future removal
  • Updated source generator correctly removes references to deleted CreateAssertionAttribute classes
  • Maintained backward compatibility transition path before removal
  • All public API snapshots properly updated across multiple target frameworks

Specific changes reviewed:

  1. Assertions attributes: Removed deprecated CreateAssertionAttribute and CreateAssertionAttribute<T> classes (TUnit.Assertions/Attributes/) that were marked obsolete in favor of AssertionFromAttribute
  2. TestContext: Removed obsolete ParallelConstraint property and ReregisterTestWithArguments method (TUnit.Core/TestContext.cs:98-146)
  3. DiscoveredTestContext: Removed deprecated SetParallelConstraint method overload (TUnit.Core/Contexts/DiscoveredTestContext.cs:98-108)
  4. Example files: Cleaned up obsolete example files (CleanArchitectureExample.cs, GenericTestExamples.cs, etc.)

✅ Performance Considerations

Positive performance impact:

  • Removes dead code that was previously carried for backward compatibility
  • Source generator simplified by removing unused attribute handling (TUnit.Assertions.SourceGenerator/Generators/AssertionMethodGenerator.cs:14-42)
  • Reduced assembly size and surface area
  • No performance regressions - only improvements through code removal

✅ Security Concerns

No security issues identified:

  • Pure code removal without introducing new functionality
  • No changes to security-sensitive areas
  • Maintains existing security posture

✅ Potential Issues

No significant issues found:

  • All snapshot tests updated correctly indicating proper API surface management
  • Source generator changes are minimal and focused
  • Follows TUnit's mandatory rules (dual-mode implementation not relevant for deletions)
  • Enhanced MethodAssertionGenerator with diagnostic rules (TUnit.Assertions.SourceGenerator/Generators/MethodAssertionGenerator.cs:68-82)

✅ Test Coverage

Proper test maintenance:

  • Public API snapshots updated across all target frameworks (.NET 4.7, 8.0, 9.0, 10.0)
  • Removed obsolete test files that were no longer needed (TUnit.TestProject/DynamicallyAddedTestsAtRuntimeTests.cs, etc.)
  • No indication of missing test coverage for remaining functionality

✅ Repository Guidelines Compliance

Follows CLAUDE.md requirements:

  • ✅ Snapshot tests properly updated for public API changes
  • ✅ No breaking changes to active APIs (only removed obsolete ones)
  • ✅ Maintains both source-generated and reflection modes (removal doesn't affect this)
  • ✅ Performance-first approach (removes unused code)

🎯 Recommendations

  1. Documentation: Consider adding a changelog entry or migration guide if not already planned
  2. Version planning: Ensure this lands in a major version if the removed APIs weren't properly marked as obsolete for long enough
  3. Communication: Verify users had adequate warning about these deprecations

🏆 Summary

This is a high-quality cleanup PR that:

  • Properly removes well-deprecated APIs
  • Maintains code quality and consistency
  • Updates all necessary snapshots and generated code
  • Follows repository conventions perfectly
  • Improves performance by reducing dead code

Recommendation: Approve

The PR demonstrates excellent maintenance practices and will help keep the TUnit codebase clean and performant.


This was referenced Oct 31, 2025
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants