Skip to content
This repository was archived by the owner on Oct 23, 2024. It is now read-only.

Conversation

@akirillov
Copy link

@akirillov akirillov commented Apr 2, 2019

What changes were proposed in this pull request?

  • Bugfix for Spark Executor ID being different from Mesos Task ID
  • Bugfix: thread-safe sequential task IDs for Executors

How was this patch tested?

Release notes

  • [Bugfix] Fixed bug for Spark Executor ID being different from Mesos Task ID

@akirillov akirillov requested a review from samvantran April 2, 2019 23:22
@akirillov akirillov force-pushed the DCOS-51158-improved-task-id-generation-and-assignment branch from a0ec2fe to e037ff9 Compare April 4, 2019 00:46
@akirillov
Copy link
Author

Closing this PR due to incompatibility with DCOS CLI. Whenever we try to use scheduler task ID as a part of child task IDs we’re going to hit this CLI issue:

dcos task log --completed --lines=1000 driver-20190404003245-0001
found more than one task with the same name: [
'ae94906c-af9c-4cb2-8976-8be248c401cf-0009-driver-20190404003245-0001-1', 
'ae94906c-af9c-4cb2-8976-8be248c401cf-0009-driver-20190404003245-0001-2', 
'ae94906c-af9c-4cb2-8976-8be248c401cf-0009-driver-20190404003245-0001-0', 
'driver-20190404003245-0001']. 

Please provide a unique task name.

@akirillov akirillov closed this Apr 4, 2019
@akirillov akirillov reopened this Apr 4, 2019
@akirillov akirillov force-pushed the DCOS-51158-improved-task-id-generation-and-assignment branch from e037ff9 to d0a19d9 Compare April 4, 2019 01:01
@akirillov
Copy link
Author

Reopened the PR due to Executor ID and thread safety bugfixes

@akirillov akirillov force-pushed the DCOS-51158-improved-task-id-generation-and-assignment branch from d0a19d9 to ac97db0 Compare April 4, 2019 17:08
Copy link

@samvantran samvantran left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

LGTM!

@akirillov akirillov merged commit 7794d38 into custom-branch-2.4.x Apr 4, 2019
@vishnu2kmohan vishnu2kmohan deleted the DCOS-51158-improved-task-id-generation-and-assignment branch May 14, 2019 09:17
alembiewski added a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 19, 2019
* Support for DSCOS_SERVICE_ACCOUNT_CREDENTIAL environment variable in MesosClusterScheduler

* File Based Secrets support

* [SPARK-723][SPARK-740] Add Metrics to Dispatcher and Driver

- Counters: The total number of times that submissions have entered states
- Timers: The duration from submit or launch until a submission entered a given state
- Histogram: The retry counts at time of retry

* Fixes to handling finished drivers

- Rename 'failed' case to 'exception'
- When a driver is 'finished', record its final MesosTaskState
- Fix naming consistency after seeing how they look in practice

* Register "finished" counters up-front

Otherwise their values are never published.

* [SPARK-692] Added spark.mesos.executor.gpus to specify the number of Executor CPUs

* [SPARK-23941][MESOS] Mesos task failed on specific spark app name (#33)

* [SPARK-23941][MESOS] Mesos task failed on specific spark app name

Port from SPARK#21014

** edit: not a direct port from upstream Spark. Changes were needed because we saw PySpark jobs fail to launch when 1) run with docker and 2) including --py-files

==============

* Shell escape only appName, mainClass, default and driverConf

Specifically, we do not want to shell-escape the --py-files. What we've
seen IRL is that for spark jobs that use docker images coupled w/ python
files, the $MESOS_SANDBOX path is escaped and results in
FileNotFoundErrors during py4j.SparkSession.getOrCreate

* [DCOS-39150][SPARK] Support unique Executor IDs in cluster managers (#36)

Using incremental integers as Executor IDs leads to a situation when Spark Executors launched by different Drivers have same IDs. This leads to a situation when Mesos Task IDs for multiple Spark Executors are the same too. This PR prepends UUID unique for a CoarseGrainedSchedulerBackend instance to numeric ID thus allowing to distinguish Executors belonging to different drivers.

This PR reverts commit ebe3c7f "[SPARK-12864][YARN] initialize executorIdCounter after ApplicationMaster killed for max n…)"

* Upgrade of Hadoop, ZooKeeper, and Jackson libraries to fix CVEs. Updates for JSON-related tests. (#43)

List of upgrades for 3rd-party libraries having CVEs:

- Hadoop: 2.7.3 -> 2.7.7. Fixes: CVE-2016-6811, CVE-2017-3166, CVE-2017-3162, CVE-2018-8009
- Jackson 2.6.5 -> 2.9.6. Fixes: CVE-2017-15095, CVE-2017-17485, CVE-2017-7525, CVE-2018-7489, CVE-2016-3720
- ZooKeeper 3.4.6 -> 3.4.13 (https://zookeeper.apache.org/doc/r3.4.13/releasenotes.html)

# Conflicts:
#	dev/deps/spark-deps-hadoop-2.6
#	dev/deps/spark-deps-hadoop-2.7
#	dev/deps/spark-deps-hadoop-3.1
#	pom.xml

* CNI Support for Docker containerizer, binding to SPARK_LOCAL_IP instead of 0.0.0.0 to properly advertise executors during shuffle (#44)

* Spark Dispatcher support for launching applications in the same virtual network by default (#45)

* [DCOS-46585] Fix supervised driver retry logic for outdated tasks (#46)

This commit fixes a bug where `--supervised` drivers would relaunch after receiving an outdated status update from a restarted/crashed agent even if they had already been relaunched and running elsewhere. In those scenarios, previous logic would cause two identical jobs to be running and ZK state would only have a record of the latest one effectively orphaning the 1st job.

* Revert "[SPARK-25088][CORE][MESOS][DOCS] Update Rest Server docs & defaults."

This reverts commit 1024875.

The change introduced in the reverted commit is breaking:
- breaks semantics of `spark.master.rest.enabled` which belongs to Spark Standalone Master only but not to SparkSubmit
- reverts the default behavior for Spark Standalone from REST to legacy RPC
- contains misleading messages in `require` assertion blocks
- prevents users from running jobs without specifying `spark.master.rest.enabled`

* [DCOS-49020] Specify user in CommandInfo for Spark Driver launched on Mesos (#49)

* [DCOS-40974] Mesos checkpointing support for Spark Drivers (#51)

* [DCOS-51158] Improved Task ID assignment for Executor tasks (#52)

* [DCOS-51454] Remove irrelevant Mesos REPL test (#54)

* [DCOS-51453] Added Hadoop 2.9 profile (#53)

* [DCOS-34235] spark.mesos.executor.memoryOverhead equivalent for the Driver when running on Mesos (#55)

* Refactoring of metrics naming to add mesos semantics and avoid clashing with existing Spark metrics (#58)

* [DCOS-34549] Mesos label NPE fix (#60)
rpalaznik pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Feb 24, 2020
* Support for DSCOS_SERVICE_ACCOUNT_CREDENTIAL environment variable in MesosClusterScheduler

* File Based Secrets support

* [SPARK-723][SPARK-740] Add Metrics to Dispatcher and Driver

- Counters: The total number of times that submissions have entered states
- Timers: The duration from submit or launch until a submission entered a given state
- Histogram: The retry counts at time of retry

* Fixes to handling finished drivers

- Rename 'failed' case to 'exception'
- When a driver is 'finished', record its final MesosTaskState
- Fix naming consistency after seeing how they look in practice

* Register "finished" counters up-front

Otherwise their values are never published.

* [SPARK-692] Added spark.mesos.executor.gpus to specify the number of Executor CPUs

* [SPARK-23941][MESOS] Mesos task failed on specific spark app name (#33)

* [SPARK-23941][MESOS] Mesos task failed on specific spark app name

Port from SPARK#21014

** edit: not a direct port from upstream Spark. Changes were needed because we saw PySpark jobs fail to launch when 1) run with docker and 2) including --py-files

==============

* Shell escape only appName, mainClass, default and driverConf

Specifically, we do not want to shell-escape the --py-files. What we've
seen IRL is that for spark jobs that use docker images coupled w/ python
files, the $MESOS_SANDBOX path is escaped and results in
FileNotFoundErrors during py4j.SparkSession.getOrCreate

* [DCOS-39150][SPARK] Support unique Executor IDs in cluster managers (#36)

Using incremental integers as Executor IDs leads to a situation when Spark Executors launched by different Drivers have same IDs. This leads to a situation when Mesos Task IDs for multiple Spark Executors are the same too. This PR prepends UUID unique for a CoarseGrainedSchedulerBackend instance to numeric ID thus allowing to distinguish Executors belonging to different drivers.

This PR reverts commit ebe3c7f "[SPARK-12864][YARN] initialize executorIdCounter after ApplicationMaster killed for max n…)"

* Upgrade of Hadoop, ZooKeeper, and Jackson libraries to fix CVEs. Updates for JSON-related tests. (#43)

List of upgrades for 3rd-party libraries having CVEs:

- Hadoop: 2.7.3 -> 2.7.7. Fixes: CVE-2016-6811, CVE-2017-3166, CVE-2017-3162, CVE-2018-8009
- Jackson 2.6.5 -> 2.9.6. Fixes: CVE-2017-15095, CVE-2017-17485, CVE-2017-7525, CVE-2018-7489, CVE-2016-3720
- ZooKeeper 3.4.6 -> 3.4.13 (https://zookeeper.apache.org/doc/r3.4.13/releasenotes.html)

* CNI Support for Docker containerizer, binding to SPARK_LOCAL_IP instead of 0.0.0.0 to properly advertise executors during shuffle (#44)

* Spark Dispatcher support for launching applications in the same virtual network by default (#45)

* [DCOS-46585] Fix supervised driver retry logic for outdated tasks (#46)

This commit fixes a bug where `--supervised` drivers would relaunch after receiving an outdated status update from a restarted/crashed agent even if they had already been relaunched and running elsewhere. In those scenarios, previous logic would cause two identical jobs to be running and ZK state would only have a record of the latest one effectively orphaning the 1st job.

* Revert "[SPARK-25088][CORE][MESOS][DOCS] Update Rest Server docs & defaults."

This reverts commit 1024875.

The change introduced in the reverted commit is breaking:
- breaks semantics of `spark.master.rest.enabled` which belongs to Spark Standalone Master only but not to SparkSubmit
- reverts the default behavior for Spark Standalone from REST to legacy RPC
- contains misleading messages in `require` assertion blocks
- prevents users from running jobs without specifying `spark.master.rest.enabled`

* [DCOS-49020] Specify user in CommandInfo for Spark Driver launched on Mesos (#49)

* [DCOS-40974] Mesos checkpointing support for Spark Drivers (#51)

* [DCOS-51158] Improved Task ID assignment for Executor tasks (#52)

* [DCOS-51454] Remove irrelevant Mesos REPL test (#54)

* [DCOS-51453] Added Hadoop 2.9 profile (#53)

* [DCOS-34235] spark.mesos.executor.memoryOverhead equivalent for the Driver when running on Mesos (#55)

* Refactoring of metrics naming to add mesos semantics and avoid clashing with existing Spark metrics (#58)

* [DCOS-34549] Mesos label NPE fix (#60)
farhan5900 pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 7, 2020
* Support for DSCOS_SERVICE_ACCOUNT_CREDENTIAL environment variable in MesosClusterScheduler

* File Based Secrets support

* [SPARK-723][SPARK-740] Add Metrics to Dispatcher and Driver

- Counters: The total number of times that submissions have entered states
- Timers: The duration from submit or launch until a submission entered a given state
- Histogram: The retry counts at time of retry

* Fixes to handling finished drivers

- Rename 'failed' case to 'exception'
- When a driver is 'finished', record its final MesosTaskState
- Fix naming consistency after seeing how they look in practice

* Register "finished" counters up-front

Otherwise their values are never published.

* [SPARK-692] Added spark.mesos.executor.gpus to specify the number of Executor CPUs

* [SPARK-23941][MESOS] Mesos task failed on specific spark app name (#33)

* [SPARK-23941][MESOS] Mesos task failed on specific spark app name

Port from SPARK#21014

** edit: not a direct port from upstream Spark. Changes were needed because we saw PySpark jobs fail to launch when 1) run with docker and 2) including --py-files

==============

* Shell escape only appName, mainClass, default and driverConf

Specifically, we do not want to shell-escape the --py-files. What we've
seen IRL is that for spark jobs that use docker images coupled w/ python
files, the $MESOS_SANDBOX path is escaped and results in
FileNotFoundErrors during py4j.SparkSession.getOrCreate

* [DCOS-39150][SPARK] Support unique Executor IDs in cluster managers (#36)

Using incremental integers as Executor IDs leads to a situation when Spark Executors launched by different Drivers have same IDs. This leads to a situation when Mesos Task IDs for multiple Spark Executors are the same too. This PR prepends UUID unique for a CoarseGrainedSchedulerBackend instance to numeric ID thus allowing to distinguish Executors belonging to different drivers.

This PR reverts commit ebe3c7f "[SPARK-12864][YARN] initialize executorIdCounter after ApplicationMaster killed for max n…)"

* Upgrade of Hadoop, ZooKeeper, and Jackson libraries to fix CVEs. Updates for JSON-related tests. (#43)

List of upgrades for 3rd-party libraries having CVEs:

- Hadoop: 2.7.3 -> 2.7.7. Fixes: CVE-2016-6811, CVE-2017-3166, CVE-2017-3162, CVE-2018-8009
- Jackson 2.6.5 -> 2.9.6. Fixes: CVE-2017-15095, CVE-2017-17485, CVE-2017-7525, CVE-2018-7489, CVE-2016-3720
- ZooKeeper 3.4.6 -> 3.4.13 (https://zookeeper.apache.org/doc/r3.4.13/releasenotes.html)

* CNI Support for Docker containerizer, binding to SPARK_LOCAL_IP instead of 0.0.0.0 to properly advertise executors during shuffle (#44)

* Spark Dispatcher support for launching applications in the same virtual network by default (#45)

* [DCOS-46585] Fix supervised driver retry logic for outdated tasks (#46)

This commit fixes a bug where `--supervised` drivers would relaunch after receiving an outdated status update from a restarted/crashed agent even if they had already been relaunched and running elsewhere. In those scenarios, previous logic would cause two identical jobs to be running and ZK state would only have a record of the latest one effectively orphaning the 1st job.

* Revert "[SPARK-25088][CORE][MESOS][DOCS] Update Rest Server docs & defaults."

This reverts commit 1024875.

The change introduced in the reverted commit is breaking:
- breaks semantics of `spark.master.rest.enabled` which belongs to Spark Standalone Master only but not to SparkSubmit
- reverts the default behavior for Spark Standalone from REST to legacy RPC
- contains misleading messages in `require` assertion blocks
- prevents users from running jobs without specifying `spark.master.rest.enabled`

* [DCOS-49020] Specify user in CommandInfo for Spark Driver launched on Mesos (#49)

* [DCOS-40974] Mesos checkpointing support for Spark Drivers (#51)

* [DCOS-51158] Improved Task ID assignment for Executor tasks (#52)

* [DCOS-51454] Remove irrelevant Mesos REPL test (#54)

* [DCOS-51453] Added Hadoop 2.9 profile (#53)

* [DCOS-34235] spark.mesos.executor.memoryOverhead equivalent for the Driver when running on Mesos (#55)

* Refactoring of metrics naming to add mesos semantics and avoid clashing with existing Spark metrics (#58)

* [DCOS-34549] Mesos label NPE fix (#60)
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants